The recent United States effort to resume the stalled talks for ending the war in Ukraine has attracted much attention beyond the battlefields, including in two strategic regions of the former Soviet Union, which the Kremlin still considers part of its influence.
An article in The New York Times published on November 13th referred to a Russian negotiating document, in which the old requirements for NATO to withdraw its forces to its positions in 1997 were repeated. Besides the great impact such an act would have on the deployment of the alliance in Europe, it would also affect NATO’s activities in the South Caucasus and Central Asia.
The agreement is still far from reached, but security experts, diplomats and politicians from Bishkek to Tbilisi are carefully following developments.
NATO scope
Co-operation NATO with these regions began in 1994, shortly after the collapse of the Soviet Union, when Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan, and Uzbekistan joined the Alliance for Partnership for Peace Programme. Tajikistan joined this programme in 2002.
The programme, designed to establish practical links in the area of security without seeking NATO membership, expanded over the decades to include military training, border security, the fight against terrorism, cyber defence and modernisation of the armed forces.
At the height of this cooperation, Georgia and Kazakhstan regularly organized multinational training, and in Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan had American military bases.
These exercises no longer develop reports between Washington and Tbilisi are privately tense while bases have been closed for a long time. Still, there are links to the security field that play a role.
NATO’s co-operation with Georgia includes cyber security, special forces and crisis management. Armenia and Azerbaijan have followed a model of more limited co-operation, while Central Asian states use these partnerships primarily for military education and training, as well as to diversify their traditional security links.
The countries would lose access to alternative military expertise, training networks, institutional reforms and Western standards, Free Europe Vakhtang Kapandze, former head of Georgia’s General Staff and former military representative to NATO and the European Union told Radio. .
Their main contribution is to improve military professionalism, interoperability, defence planning, institutional sustainability and the ability to co-operate with numerous international partners, he added.
Kapadase stressed that losing these ties would force countries to seek alternative partners, which could be Russia or China.
NATO’s response: Test of credibility?
Asked by Radio Free Europe to comment on Moscow’s demands, which was reported, an official of NATO rejected them without directly mentioning Russia.
Any decision on further development of these partnerships is exclusive preliminary of NATO allies and associated partners, the official said.
Kapadase said she believes NATO will try to defend these principles, but added that its ability to do so depends on political unity, especially between Washington and its European allies.
In the end, NATO’s credibility depends on ensuring that smaller states are not treated as leverage, Kapandze said. Any agreement affecting Ukraine, Georgia or other post-Soviet countries should directly include these countries and respect their sovereign elections, separately when the vast Black Sea and Central Asia region deserves no less strategic attention than the Baltic states.
So far, governments throughout Central Asia and the South Caucasus have not reacted publicly to the Russian document, which appeared in public. It remains unclear whether Moscow has officially communicated its position to these governments before, according to reports, to distribute the negotiating document during peace talks between the US, Russia and Ukraine at Abu Dhabi on November 10th and 11th.
Analysts in Kyrgyzstan, a country that is closely linked to Moscow through trade and the Organisation of the Kolektive Security Treaty ( Russia-led CSTO warned that demands Moscow is reportedly presenting directly affect the region’s independence.
Political analyst from Kyrgyzstan, Emil Yoroev, told Radio Europe’s Kyrgyz Service Free Europe that this confirms the sovereignty of Central Asian countries. First of all, it is an attempt to limit their right to define and draft their independent foreign policy and decide for themselves who they will co-operate with.
Yoroev said he does not expect Kyrgyzstan or neighbouring countries to have formal diplomatic protests, but argued that leaders of the region should directly confront Moscow at closed meetings during high-level summits.
These issues should be raised at those very meetings and should become clear that our countries will not accept such actions, he said.
Bakyt Ammanbaev, former ambassador to Kyrgyzstan to the US, went further, arguing that Moscow has no authority to dictate the region’s foreign partnerships and that silence is not enough.
Speaking to the Kirgiz Radio Service Free Europe, Ammanbaev said no country has the right to establish and lead foreign policy on behalf of Central Asian states.
It would be entirely appropriate for the foreign ministers of Central Asian countries to gather and express a clear and concrete attitude, he added.
The signal where the truth speaks before the news!
Source Layer: Signal